Trusted Leader Blog

Why Great Leaders Thrive When Good Ones Fail During a Workplace Crisis

Written by Marie-Claire Ross | Tue, Feb 24, 2026

Implementing change in the workplace often creates pressure, uncertainty, and emotional reactions - especially during a workplace crisis.

Successful leaders don’t avoid this stress. They transform it.

When pressure hits, most leaders react automatically from fear in ways that unintentionally shut down thinking, reduce trust, and escalate problems. The best leaders do something different. They pause, reframe what’s happening, and activate responses that help their teams stay grounded, think clearly, and move forward together.

This difference in response is what separates leaders who just survive workplace change from those who lead others through it with confidence and capability.

 

How Leaders Manage Workplace Change during a Workplace Crisis

 

How do you react when you feel attacked, criticised, or receive bad news?

For many leaders, these moments trigger fast, defensive responses. Words come out sharper than intended. Control tightens. People feel blamed, reassured too quickly, or shut down altogether. What started as a challenge turns into unnecessary drama.

Yet there is a better way.

As an executive coach, I work with leaders on how to respond when change feels threatening - not by suppressing emotion, but by regulating it. What I consistently see is this: high-performing leaders don’t react less. They react differently.

They are calmer, more composed, and more intentional in how they respond when it matters most.

To explain this, I use what I call The Leadership Capacity Ladder: From Reactor to Activator.

 

The Two Ladders of Leadership Response

 

When bad news hits - a missed deadline, a restructure, a client escalation, a sudden shift in strategy - we all start in the same place: Underlying Fear (Amygdala threat.

Your brain’s threat system switches on, preparing you to protect yourself.

From there, you tend to either choose a rung from the Reactor or the Activator Ladder. 


The Reactor Ladder (Fear-Fuelled protection)


On this side, your reactions are fast, automatic, and defensive. You usually jump straight to one or more of the reactive rungs: 

Control – “I must fix this myself. I can’t trust others to handle it.”

Victim/Scarcity – “We don’t have enough time, people, or resources. There’s nothing we can do.”

Need for Approval – “If I fail, they won’t respect me. I have to look in control.”

Identity Defence – “This proves I’m not good enough. I can’t afford to be wrong.”

Blame – “This is their fault. Why can’t they get it right?”

These reactions can look decisive in the moment, but they narrow thinking, reduce psychological safety, and keep teams stuck in threat mode  - especially during periods of workplace change or crisis.



The Activator Ladder (Regulated, Intentional Leadership)

 

On the Activator side, leaders still feel the stress - but they don’t let it run the show.

Stress becomes a signal to slow down internally, rather than speed up externally. From this steadier internal position, leaders choose responses that open thinking instead of closing it.

Pause & Clarity

Activator leaders interrupt the reflex to react quickly in order to look decisive. They take a brief internal pause  - even just six seconds - to regulate their nervous system.

In that pause, they reach for grounding thoughts such as:

  • “Everything will work out for the best.”
  • “That’s interesting.”

This reset allows them to ask clearer questions:

  • “What’s actually happening here?”
  • “What do I know for sure?”

From there, they can intentionally step onto other rungs of the ladder to get people thinking differently about the issue at hand or even themselves

Learning & Possibility – “What can we learn from this? What might this open up?”

Authenticity & Courage – “How can I name what’s hard without attacking or collapsing?”

Purpose & Contribution – “What matters most right now? How can we create value together through this change?”

Empowerment – “How will the wiser future version of me – and my team – navigate this?”

Any rung on the Activator ladder is a better choice than staying stuck on the Reactor side. This isn’t about being perfect or “always empowered.” It’s about choosing capacity over protection in the moment.

 

The Activator Edge: Emotional Regulation in Action

 

Your brain is wired to default to the Reactor ladder. Under stress, the amygdala — the brain’s threat centre — hijacks thinking and pushes you toward fight (control, blame), flight (avoidance, appeasing), or freeze (victim, stuck).

Activator leaders unlearn some powerful assumptions:

  • that speed always equals strength
  • that reassurance is the same as care
  • that control is the only way to stay safe

Instead, they practice a different pattern. They:

  • take a six-second micro-pause to regulate before responding
  • name what’s really happening rather than smoothing over or panicking
  • stay present with discomfort long enough for better options and meaning to emerge
  • involve others in thinking instead of rescuing or blaming

The result is a calm, grounded leadership presence that helps others feel safer and think more clearly. Teams recover faster, take greater ownership, and are more willing to speak honestly during workplace change.

 

Why Reactors Struggle (Even When They're "Successful")

 

Many high-achieving leaders become successful through Reactor behaviours — control, urgency, image management. But over time, the costs accumulate:

  • Teams feel micromanaged or disempowered
  • Trust erodes as fear spreads
  • Leaders burn out defending their identity

Reactors focus on surviving the threat.
Activators focus on creating from it.


Real Leadership in Action


Imagine a missed deadline during a major change initiative.


Reactor path: Fear → Control ("Fix it now!") → Blame ("Why can't you get this right?").

Activator path: Fear → Pause → Possibility ("What opportunity does this reveal?") Empowerment ("How will we all grow capability  through this?").

The Activator doesn’t ignore the problem. They reframe it, involve others, and strengthen the team’s capacity to handle future challenges. Results still matter - but so does honesty and resilience.


Leadership in Times of Crisis

 

The next time workplace change triggers pressure, notice your default Reactor rung. Then deliberately step across and ask the matching Activator question.

Over time, this rewires your response - from reactive leadership to creative, grounded leadership.

Leaders don’t rise by avoiding fear.
They rise by choosing a better ladder.

Which rung will you step onto next?

If you want to know more about how to be an Activator leader, then come and join my free webinar on 10 March. It will be filled with tips and tricks. If you can't make it, register anyway and you'll receive the recording.